Celebrating the undiscovered charms of Caribbean travel & culture.
Deep Water Cay Pool | SBPR
Bahamas, Deep Water Cay

Checking Into Deep Water Cay, The Bahamas

Checking Into Deep Water Cay, The Bahamas

It’s a pretty long drive (at least by Bahamas standards) from the airport in Freeport to McLean’s Town at the far eastern edge of Grand Bahama Island. The journey extends a good hour and change, tracing along an almost entirely straight line through flat and fairly nondescript brush land.

Exciting, this drive most certainly is not.

The payoff at the end for those checking into Deep Water Cay, though, is as thrilling and rewarding as any I’ve encountered anywhere in The Bahamas…

Deep Water Cay Marina near McLean's Town | SBPR
Deep Water Cay Marina near McLean’s Town | SBPR
All gassed up and ready to go over to Deep Water Cay | SBPR
All gassed up and ready to go over to Deep Water Cay | SBPR

It sits a hefty stone’s throws from mainland Grand Bahama, yet Deep Water Cay espouses every bit of the exclusive and secluded private island feel so desired by discerning travelers.

Grand Bahama Island, just a stone's throw away | SBPR
Grand Bahama Island, just a stone’s throw away | SBPR
Secluded beaches lay sprinkled about Deep Water Cay | SBPR
Secluded beaches lay sprinkled about Deep Water Cay | SBPR

At the same time, though, this is a place absolutely (and blessedly) devoid of stuffiness and pretension; where guests and staff become fast friends, a shared camaraderie readily apparent in the smiles shared by all. Smiles that hint at the question that seemed to be on the minds of every guest I met here during my stay:

Can you believe how great this place is?

Deep Water Cay infinity pool | SBPR
Deep Water Cay infinity pool | SBPR

My own personal answer was no. Truly, I had zero idea what to expect upon arriving here on a sunny Thursday afternoon last October. All I really knew of Deep Water was that it was legendary among fly fishing circles; circles of which I had precious little previous knowledge.

Flats just offshore Deep Water Cay | SBPR
Flats just offshore Deep Water Cay | SBPR

Still, I’d also heard that the accommodations on the island had recently been expanded and enhanced, lending a more elegant island style to the formerly rustic “all boys club” aesthetic of the late-1950’s, when the initial fishing outpost was established here.

This proved true in most every way imaginable.

From the meals, a wonderfully communal five-star dining experience where all guests eat together at long tables like family, to the in-room amenities and comforts of my 2,000+ square-foot two-story villa by the sea, the thoughtful luxuries at Deep Water Cay make you feel cared for… relaxed… at home.

Dining Room at The Lodge at Deep Water Cay | SBPR
Dining Room at The Lodge at Deep Water Cay | SBPR

Speaking of that villa, though, it was pretty spectacular. Dubbed “Gumbo Limbo,” it’s located right next to The Lodge, the social hub of the island where you’ll find the pool, The Blue Hole Bar & Grill, The Dining Room, pool table, gaming room, and a cozy little gym downstairs.

Gumbo Limbo villa at Deep Water Cay | SBPR
Gumbo Limbo villa at Deep Water Cay | SBPR

The location couldn’t be better, but with three bedrooms, four baths, a sprawling gourmet kitchen, comfy living room, expansive second floor balcony extending across the entire width of the house, and sunset views like these, I hardly ever wanted to leave.

Pool view from Gumbo Limbo | SBPR
Pool view from Gumbo Limbo | SBPR

My first-ever bonefishing adventure, a great snorkeling excursion, and some random adventuring around the island pulled me away, of course. Even without those diversions, though, I would’ve ventured out just to mix and mingle with the other guests and fantastic staff at Deep Water Cay.

Like all of the best hotels and resorts I’ve been lucky enough to visit on my travels, the thing that makes Deep Water Cay most special to me is the people you meet there.

The beauty that surrounds, the ultra laid-back vibe, those smiles I mentioned earlier, and everyone gathering together at the end of each day – it all breeds a special kind of magic that goes far beyond luxurious appointments, gourmet cuisine, and the like.

Go down to the dock by Shervin and learn to crack conch like a champ. Raise a Sands (or two) with Captain Mervin and learn about the many generations of his family that have fished these waters. Strike up a game of pool or Bimini ring toss with fellow guests at The Lodge. Laugh with the lady bartenders at The Blue Hole while enduring enjoying the signature Deep Water Iced Tea.

Somewhere along the way you’ll get a small taste of the real Bahamas… one that will surely draw you back soon.

For more on the fabulous guest experience at Deep Water Cay, be sure to visit them online.