Stays2 of 5

Company House Hotel has the charm you’d expect from a historic boutique hotel—cozy bar, antique furniture, historic photos, and décor pulled from the past.

Two Sandals By The Sea Inn, set on a hillside overlooking Red Hook on the east end of St. Thomas, is an ideal home away from home in the Caribbean.

The Fred along the historic downtown Frederiksted waterfront, the first all-new hotel of any real significance to debut on our home island in some 30 years.

Arawak Bay The Inn at Salt River seems purpose-built for anyone seeking to channel a real, local, Crucian hospitality experience while visiting St. Croix.

Golden Rock Inn is an idyllic clutch of 11 guesthouses peppered in the middle of over 100 acres of lush gardens carpeting the slopes of Mount Nevis. If you want to immerse yourself in romantic nature, look no further. You can even book a windmill as your room. Seriously.

Mount Nevis Hotel and Beach Club delivers spectacular views and access to all Nevis has to offer in a quaint, quiet, and classic Caribbean package.