Dinghy's Beach Bar Blue Umbrellas, Water Island, USVI | SBPR

Unpacking St. Thomas and St. John, USVI – May 2018

Editor’s note: Patrick and I are just back from a week’s long adventure in the parts of the USVI hardest-hit by hurricanes Irma and Maria last year – St. Thomas and St. John. How are these islands faring now, nearly nine months since the storms? Should you plan on visiting here anytime soon? Here’s a sneak peak at the stories we’ll tell with all the answers…

Post-Trip Mood

Shocked. Like most Crucians, we’d never given St. Thomas much of a chance, the long simmering sibling rivalry between our islands building a brick wall of bias in our minds that we never really had any desire to scale, much less break through. In more recent years, I’d actually come to soften my stance on St. Thomas. Patrick, on the other hand, remained resolute in his disdain for all things STT. This trip, though, changed everything for us. The St. Thomas we experienced was as beautiful and welcoming in an authentically West Indian way as most anywhere we’ve visited together. St. John was much the same, of course, but we’ve always loved St. John. The real revelation of this trip was just how sweet St. Thomas really is right now.

Another MAJOR highlight of our trip: hanging on this incredible beach on Thatch Cay | SBPR
Another MAJOR highlight of our trip: hanging on this incredible beach on Thatch Cay | SBPR
The Good

No crowds. As we noted in St. Croix back in December, the major impact of last year’s hurricanes have kept the crowds away in St. Thomas. Imagine downtown Charlotte Amalie with little-to-no traffic. Imagine having amazing beaches like Lindquist and Brewers Bay virtually all to yourself. Yeah, that’s what we just enjoyed, which, again, makes right now the very best time for uncommon travelers to pay St. Thomas a visit.

As for St. John, Trunk Bay, Cinnamon Bay, Mongoose Junction, and downtown Cruz Bay felt a good bit more crowded than anywhere we roamed in St. Thomas. The island itself bears more hurricane scars than St. Thomas, particularly in Coral Bay and the far eastern region, but the good times are very much still rolling all over the island.

This is the coolest guy in Cruz Bay, St. John, USVI. You'll never guess why... | SBPR
This is the coolest guy in Cruz Bay, St. John, USVI. You’ll never guess why… | SBPR
The Other Good

Superior service. In a popular tourism hot spot like St. Thomas, service is generally not worthy of praise. Not so right now. Several innkeepers, restauranteurs, and bartenders noted to us that no one is taking tourist dollars for granted anymore. Service and pricing were excellent just about everywhere we ordered anything. Special high marks go to The Longboard in Cruz Bay; Sun Dog Cafe in Mongoose Junction; Thali Indian Grill and Fish Tails in Red Hook; and  Win Mill 2.0 in Frenchtown, the BEST place to watch the NBA Playoffs anywhere, assuming you’re looking for a very local experience. We even met a mobile chef who will happily deliver tasty local treats to wherever you might be. The guy’s pates, in particular, are ON POINT. Can’t wait to tell you about this guy…

Natural Beauty of St. John, USVI endures | SBPR
Natural Beauty of St. John, USVI endures | SBPR
The Bad

We had to leave. Yeah, it was THAT nice!

Wiling the day away at Water Island, USVI | SBPR
Wiling the day away at Water Island, USVI | SBPR
The Great

Impossible to pick one thing here. I mean, there was that secret beach we found by accident in St. Thomas, the little hike we had to make to get there, and the old plantation ruins and graveyard we found a few feet from the surf – a MUST for uncommon travelers! Then there was swimming with a stingray in the shallows of Trunk Bay, the water and beach just as pristine as always. Oh, and no mention of great things in St. Thomas could be complete without Jackie. if you’ve ever been past the airport here, then it’s likely you’ve seen her, met her, or eaten her super-fantastic West Indian cuisine. If you haven’t, then I HIGHLY recommend you do next time you’re in STT. Jackie is just about the sweetest woman I’ve ever met on my travels, and her food is even sweeter than she is!

I guess the best of the great, though, would have to be the incredible places we stayed – Two Sandals By The Sea in Red Hood and Bellavista Bed and Breakfast in the hills above Charlotte Amalie. With most every major hotel in St. Thomas and St. John still on the mend, the islands’ smaller inns, villas, and B&B properties are now in the spotlight. We couldn’t recommend these two options more highly. Both made us feel right at home from the jump, Helen at Two Sandals and Wendy at Bellavista showing us the kind of individual care and attention that makes all the difference in creating truly special travel memories.

Positively postcard views from Bellavista B&B in St. Thomas, USVI | SBPR
Positively postcard views from Bellavista B&B in St. Thomas, USVI | SBPR

So yeah, St. Thomas really, really surprised us, and St. John is still every bit the Love City it’s always been.

Now is most definitely the time to visit both spots.

We have a dedicated week of coverage on St. Thomas/St. John coming soon to elaborate on all of this. Stay tuned…

Last updated by Steve Bennett on .

Related Posts

Rock City, USVI – St. Thomas/St. John Week | Credit: Patrick Bennett
🇻🇮St. Thomas

Welcome To St. Thomas/St. John Week!

Miracles are made in 9 months, so it was fitting that we found ourselves back in St. Thomas/St. John 9 months post-hurricanes Irma and Maria.
🇻🇮U.S. Virgin Islands

Taking the ferry from Red Hook to St. John: Wish You Were Here

Taking the ferry across Pillsbury Sound from Red Hook, St. Thomas over to Cruz Bay, St. John US Virgin Islands.
Magens Bay morning, St. Thomas, USVI | SBPR
🇻🇮St. Thomas

Up Next: St. Thomas and St. John, USVI

We're about to embark on a weeklong adventure to gauge for ourselves just how things are really coming along in post-Hurricane Irma/Maria St. Thomas and St. John. Should you consider traveling to St. Thomas and St. John, USVI this summer? We'll start getting some answers beginning tomorrow.
Send this to a friend