Anguilla Crayfish by Patrick Bennett

Anguilla Crayfish: The Tasty Truth Behind This Misnomer

If you’ve ever been to Louisiana, you may be confused as to how a tiny island in the Caribbean (with practically no fresh water) could become famous for serving up mouthwatering Anguilla crayfish. The secret to this unlikely success lies in an age-old habit within the region of not being too particular with names.

Fast and loose with Caribbean naming

For instance, many West Indians actually have two names. Take my father. On his Trinidadian birth certificate, his name is clearly designated as being John R. Bennett, yet his family and old friends all call him “Carl.” Turns out, my dad’s mom just liked the sound of Carl better.

The same laid back attitude towards naming also applies to food. Gooseberries in the Caribbean? Not what you’re thinking. We also eat green figs, mountain chicken, and dolphin. But you’d probably know these by their other names: bananas, frogs and fish.

What is the Anguilla crayfish?

Which brings me to the Scooby Doo style unmasking of the Anguilla crayfish… aka the spotted spiny lobster (Panulirus guttatus)… aka the Guinea chick lobster… aka one delicious lunch! So, no, this isn’t your N’awlins freshwater crawdaddy. This is a very different beast.

Smaller and sweeter than the Caribbean staple of regular-old spiny lobster, “crayfish” can be found adorning menus all across the tiny island of Anguilla — from the most high-end establishments all the way down to the roadside BBQ’s and everywhere in between. Locals and the newly converted alike sing their praises as being “soo much better than lobster,” and add statements like “I never eat lobster anymore, only crayfish!”

Shhh, don’t tell them they’ve been eating lobster all along!

Open season on crayfish

Unfortunately, for the crayfish population, there’s no designated season for pulling these treats from the waters surrounding Anguilla. But fortunately for you, that means they can be enjoyed whenever you happen to find yourself on-island.

Some restaurants in more touristy areas have been known to charge up to $45 US dollars a plate for this speckled spiny species, though, so you’re best bet to get this taste of the Caribbean is to go local.


Last updated by Patrick Bennett on .

Related Posts

mauby drink

Mauby – A Taste of the Caribbean That’s Not for Everyone

Mauby, an island beverage made by boiling a specific buckthorn bark, is a classic taste of the Caribbean that's not for everyone.

Browning Sauce Makes Everything Better — Easily

Browning sauce at its core is really just burnt sugar. Whether you get it in a bottle or make it yourself at home, it's an essential taste of the Caribbean.

Many Splendored Mango Chutney: Taste of the Caribbean

Here's an easy recipe for making mango chutney, plus a few reasons why you'll want to include it in everything worth eating...
Send this to a friend