"Uncommon envy"5 of 9

Eight guest rooms, 10 boat slips, and an over-water bar/restaurant, set on an islet measuring one acre – this was the old Saba Rock.

My next trip to Antigua will definitely include a Monday night... and a lot more time at Castaways.

Saba, seems to be the perfect destination for me. I mean, you can't get any more uncommon in the Caribbean than an island without any beaches, right?

I was hooked at my first glance of Grenada's Grenadines.

To sleep above the sea in exotic and remote Guna Yala, Panama – it's long ranked among my ultimate travel dreams.

Luxury? That's primarily the province of Seven Mile Beach in the Caymans... Or at least so I thought until I heard about Le Soleil d'Or on Cayman Brac.

Jamaica is one of a handful of places that to me inspires envy just in name alone. Rockhouse is one big reason why.

Anguilla has as much of which to be envious as anywhere in the Caribbean, especially in the area of hotels and villa accommodations like the sublime Sea Villa.

Our search for the uncommon in all corners of the Caribbean has led me to Nicaragua's Little Corn Island, my interest piqued by its inherent kookiness.